The criticism continued with Congress accusing the Left of being against progress and development. Mr. Tata was in agreement Friday, when he said that the West Bengal government would not allow enough land for the plant, and consequently the Tata Group pulled out after facing “much aggression,” from the Left. This is liberal because a failure of the institutions, in this case the government of West Bengal and the Tata Group, to communicate effectively. Thus the Tata Group became fed up and decided to shutter their plant before it even produced a single Nano, the world’s cheapest car that Tata had hoped to introduce later this month.